Evaluative Criteria for World Wide Web Resources
-
Who provided the information?
-
Was the creator
-
a company with a commercial interest?
-
a public advocacy group with a biased angle?
-
an individual?
-
If a person was responsible for the document, what qualifications does
he/she
possess?
-
When was the document created?
-
Web information often isn't updated as frequently as it should be.
-
Check the last line of the page to find out whether the information provider
included a "date of last publication."
-
If necessary, e-mail the page's provider.
-
Is the document peer-reviewed?
-
The most authoritative publications utilize this approach
-
i.e., they are not published unless an anonymous panel of experts in a
field .determines the presence of sufficient merit.
-
What references to the material have been provided?
-
Are any citations to publications of other Web documents provided to back
up the
author's contentions?
(b) Are the links up-to-date, and are they as authoritative as the current
document?
Web document evaluation exercise:
Review the following web-derived item and assess its quality, particularly
in comparison to more traditional formats. Should it be considered as a
potential acquisition for libraries?